Various Cases of Using Apostrophe

M.N 12/13/2016. 1 answers, 46 views
punctuation

I have two questions on using apostrophe:

  1. Why an apostrophe has been used here after "s" in "The 69’ers’ drummer, Tom Callaghan" while the same thing does not happen after "s" in the "Beatles" in the following sentence? The band was playing the old Beatles songs. (Not ... the old Beatles' songs.)

  2. Why do they say St. James' Park (in Newcastle) but St. James's Park (in London)?!

1 Answers


Peter 12/14/2016.

69'ers' drummer

because the drummer is part of the Aussie band (possessive)

St James's Park (London)

because it was name after St James the Less (possessive)

St James' Park (Newcastle)

the difference in spelling might be guessed to be due to

  • Geordies didn't want a park with the same name as one in London
  • The stadium took the name of the area which used "James"
  • Geordies don't know how to spell

There is an extensive description of the conundrum here.
Note that there was a time when the stadium was spelled "St James's Park".

Beatles

in your example is being used as an adjective same as in

United Airlines seating chart

It is "a Beatles song" meaning

The song is (sung) by the Beatles

but it would be "the Beatles' contract" with their record company that got it produced.

3 comments
M.N 12/13/2016
And in "the old Beatles songs" there's no sense of possession? So who the songs belong to?!
1 Dr. Funk 12/14/2016
I would say that in "the old Beatles songs", "Beatles" is functioning as a proper adjective.
user32753 12/19/2016
@Dr.Funk and Peter are on the money here. Also, James' v. James's is a merely a matter of preference. You'll see it both ways everywhere. It's not even geographic. The only time I've seen it more is with ancient names (like Socrates'), but even then, I have seen it the other way (Socrates's), too.

Related questions

Hot questions

Language

Popular Tags