Does magic missile hit silent image's illusory creature?

Jack 03/31/2016. 3 answers, 815 views
dnd-5e spells illusion

Magic missile says:

You create three glowing darts of magical force. Each dart hits a creature of your choice that you can see within range.

Silent image says:

You create the image of an object, a creature, or some other visible phenomenon....

If one caster creates an illusory creature with silent image what happens when another caster targets that illusory creature with magic missile? Assuming of course that the mm caster is shooting first and asking questions later, ie, rather than using his or her action to investigate the illusion is simply choosing to attack it. Or I suppose the mm caster might have failed the investigation check. Either way, the mm caster believes the illusion to be real.

My own inclination would be to rule that magic missile would in fact appear to hit the illusory creature, but I can't find much to either support that conclusion, or to support another.

3 Answers

LegendaryDude 04/01/2016.

No, Magic Missile does not hit the target. It sails right through it. Magic Missile targets a creature, and in your mind the illusion is a creature.

Each dart hits a creature of your choice that you can see within range.

The end result is that the Magic Missile is cast, the slot is expended, but it does not hit anything unless you specified more than one creature and any of those other creatures are valid targets (non-illusionary creatures). This may give the caster reason to believe his target is not quite what he expected, and may give cause to inspect the Silent Image more closely.

As for what actually happens in the narrative when this occurs?

Let's say the caster casts magic missile and decides to hit one (unknown to him) illusionary target and two other real targets, one missile each. The missiles streak towards their targets, and hit the two real ones. The third target is an illusion and can't be hit, so the missile passes right through him. This may tip the caster off that this may be an illusion. This is the most likely scenario.

The other option is for the DM to say, "that one isn't a valid target. Try again." This, of course, tips the player off, and lets the player choose a new target for his missile. This way involves metagame information, pulls the players out of the scene, and is probably a lot less fun.

2 KorvinStarmast 03/31/2016
If the illusion is successful, the caster of MM sees a creature (albeit illusory) and shoots a missile at it. As you say, it doesn't HIT the creature of choice, as it isn't a creature, and the rest becomes a complication. Illusions once again raise unique issues/problems. Are you saying that the missile doesn't even fly, or that it just doesn't hit anything and when it reaches extreme range it dissipates?
2 Jack 03/31/2016
@LegendaryDude Consider two cases: 1) what you are describing - the spell fizzles, the missile doesn't hit anything, vs 2) the missile hits (or appears to hit) the illusion. In both cases the missile is wasted and perhaps the whole slot is. The only difference is that in 1) the magic fails at the fingertips and 2) the magic fails at the "target". I can't find anything that makes it clear that one should happen vs. the other.
1 LegendaryDude 04/01/2016
@KorvinStarmast I didn't say what exactly happens because the rules don't. I think it's best left to the DM to decide. I'll admit I was thinking in terms of 3.5/PF spell failure, where you if you target something invalid your spell simply fails but as far as I know 5e has no such rule. Illusions introduce a flaw in those rules, too, because it risks giving away an illusion by virtue of spell failure. I think in my own games, I'd rule the missile as flying towards the target and passing through it,
LegendaryDude 04/01/2016
@Jack Nor I, which is why I didn't say what happens in my answer. As I mentioned in my previous comment, it's probably best left as an exercise to the DM when it comes up in the game.
KorvinStarmast 04/01/2016
I don't think that "spell fizzles" adds value to the response for 5e, though I do understand where it's coming from. That the spell has no effect, and how that looks (see Dale M's four cases) looks to be in the narrative hands of the DM.

J. A. Streich 04/01/2016.

I read it this way. The spell creates an image of a creature, and the caster believes it to be a creature, so that can be a valid target of the spell. The spell hits the space the illusion is in. Since the illusion has been interacted with, it is now clear the creature is an illusion.

Physical interaction with the image reveals it to be an illusion, because things can pass through it.

In regards to targeting the illusion:

Each dart hits a creature of your choice that you can see within range.

You are choosing a creature, that creature just happens to not really exist. You believe it is a creature, so you choose it as a target.

1 Jack 03/31/2016
J.A., you say "it is now clear the creature is an illusion". That certainly seems likely, but is that an absolute certainty? It might be a trivial distinction, but I don't think it is an automatic result.
Jack 04/01/2016
He didn't say it passed through the target on contact, he said it hits the space the illusion is in.
J. A. Streich 04/01/2016
Thanks Lino, I've added the text from the Silent Image spell related to interaction.

Dale M 04/01/2016.

Each dart hits a creature of your choice that you can see within range.


You create the image of ... a creature

An image of a creature is not a creature so it is an invalid target for a spell.

If the player had said "I target this statue with magic missile because I think its a stone golem" and it isn't, you have exactly the same circumstances.

So, what happens?

So, what happens next is up to the DM because this is one of those circumstances that the RAW do not foresee; in particular the rules on Targeting on p.204 don't help. Essentially I can see these choices (others may occur to you):

  • You can't do that, try something else with your action
  • You lose your action, no spell is cast
  • You lose your action and the spell slot with no other effect
  • You lose your action and the spell slot and magic missiles impact the image/statue with no effect

Except in the first case, you have met the criteria of using an action to interact with the image so that you now know that it is an illusion. - Download Hi-Res Songs

1 The Chainsmokers

Beach House flac

The Chainsmokers. 2018. Writer: Andrew Taggart.
2 (G)I-DLE


(G)I-DLE. 2018. Writer: Riot Music Team;Harloe.
3 Ariana Grande

​Thank U, Next flac

Ariana Grande. 2018. Writer: Crazy Mike;Scootie;Victoria Monét;Tayla Parx;TBHits;Ariana Grande.
4 Anne-Marie

Rewrite The Stars flac

Anne-Marie. 2018. Writer: Benj Pasek;Justin Paul.
5 Clean Bandit

Baby flac

Clean Bandit. 2018. Writer: Jack Patterson;Kamille;Jason Evigan;Matthew Knott;Marina;Luis Fonsi.
6 Nicki Minaj

No Candle No Light flac

Nicki Minaj. 2018. Writer: Denisia “Blu June” Andrews;Kathryn Ostenberg;Brittany "Chi" Coney;Brian Lee;TJ Routon;Tushar Apte;ZAYN;Nicki Minaj.
7 BlackPink

Kiss And Make Up flac

BlackPink. 2018. Writer: Soke;Kny Factory;Billboard;Chelcee Grimes;Teddy Park;Marc Vincent;Dua Lipa.
8 Imagine Dragons

Bad Liar flac

Imagine Dragons. 2018. Writer: Jorgen Odegard;Daniel Platzman;Ben McKee;Wayne Sermon;Aja Volkman;Dan Reynolds.

Waste It On Me flac

BTS. 2018. Writer: Steve Aoki;Jeff Halavacs;Ryan Ogren;Michael Gazzo;Nate Cyphert;Sean Foreman;RM.
10 Halsey

Without Me flac

Halsey. 2018. Writer: Halsey;Delacey;Louis Bell;Amy Allen;Justin Timberlake;Timbaland;Scott Storch.
11 Little Mix

Woman Like Me flac

Little Mix. 2018. Writer: Nicki Minaj;Steve Mac;Ed Sheeran;Jess Glynne.
12 Brooks

Limbo flac

Brooks. 2018.
13 Fitz And The Tantrums

HandClap flac

Fitz And The Tantrums. 2017. Writer: Fitz And The Tantrums;Eric Frederic;Sam Hollander.
14 Backstreet Boys

Chances flac

Backstreet Boys. 2018.
15 Lady Gaga

I'll Never Love Again flac

Lady Gaga. 2018. Writer: Benjamin Rice;Lady Gaga.
16 Diplo

Close To Me flac

Diplo. 2018. Writer: Ellie Goulding;Savan Kotecha;Peter Svensson;Ilya;Swae Lee;Diplo.
17 Rita Ora

Velvet Rope flac

Rita Ora. 2018.
18 Bradley Cooper

Always Remember Us This Way flac

Bradley Cooper. 2018. Writer: Lady Gaga;Dave Cobb.
19 Imagine Dragons

Machine flac

Imagine Dragons. 2018. Writer: Wayne Sermon;Daniel Platzman;Dan Reynolds;Ben McKee;Alex Da Kid.
20 Erika Sirola

Speechless flac

Erika Sirola. 2018. Writer: Teemu Brunila;Stefan Dabruck;Jürgen Dohr;Guido Kramer;Dennis Bierbrodt;Chris Braide;Robin Schulz.

Related questions

Hot questions


Popular Tags